Institut für Soziologie
Adrian Marangoni
BA MA
MASTERSTUDIUM
SOZIOLOGIE
Institut für Soziologie
Betreuerin:
Univ.-Prof. Dr.
Libora Oates-Indruchová, PhD
Science Under Pressure – A Systematic Analysis
of Openness and Censorship in Research
Scientific openness has become a central ideal of contemporary research policy. It promises greater accessibility, transparency, traceability, and reusability of scientific work. Under restrictive conditions, however, precisely this visibility can become risky: for researchers, participants, data, local collaborators, or institutions. Starting from this tension, the thesis examines how scientists navigate between the ideals of Open Science and the constraints of censorship, self‑censorship, and political pressure. The focus is not on whether openness is simply possible or impossible, but on how it is practically organized in contexts shaped by surveillance, institutional pressure, political sensitivity, and unequal vulnerability. The theoretical framework brings together debates on Open Science, the FAIR and CARE principles, epistemic cultures, and situated openness with approaches from censorship theory, particularly constituent censorship, visibility, disciplinary power, self-censorship, and dispersed censorship. Methodologically, the study is based on a qualitative literature analysis followed by type formation according to Kelle and Kluge. On this basis, recurring forms of scientific navigation under restrictive conditions were reconstructed. The analysis develops four types: protection through invisibility, continuation through semantic adaptation, graduated openness, and continuation through alternative circulation spaces. The findings show that Open Science does not simply disappear under restrictive conditions. Rather, openness is shifted, limited, translated, protected, delayed, relocated, and sometimes deliberately made invisible. Openness is therefore not understood as the mere maximization of access, but as a situated, powerful, and risky practice that must constantly be negotiated between scientific traceability, ethical responsibility, and protection from possible sanctions.